ON THE ISSUE OF PHILOSOPHICAL AFFILIATION OF THE HISTORIAN POLYBIUS
Tyzhov Andrei Yakovlevich
Saint Petersburg State University
Abstract. The article examines certain issues regarding the identification of the ideological and philosophical attitude of the famous historian of the Hellenistic period Polybius from Megalopolis (200-138 B.C.), the author of "The Histories" in 40 volumes. The paper analyzes modern views on this problem. The issue is solved in the following aspects: Polybius - philosopher-stoic and Polybius - philosopher-eclectic. The author aims to deny the widely accepted in antique studies opinion on the stoic affiliation of Polybius’ views.
Key words and phrases: Полибий, "Всеобщая история", стоицизм, перипатетики, историописание, Ахейский союз, Рим, Мегалополь, культурное влияние, философская преемственность, Polybius, "The Histories", stoicism, peripatetic school, chronicle writing, The Achaean League, Rome, Megalopolis, cultural influence, philosophical continuity
Open the whole article in PDF format. Free PDF-files viewer can be downloaded .
References:
Vasil'evskii V. G. Politicheskaya reforma i sotsial'noe dvizhenie v Drevnei Gretsii v period ee upadka. SPb., 1869.
Polents M. Stoya. Istoriya dukhovnogo dvizheniya. SPb., 2015.
Tyzhov A. Ya. Byl li Polibii priverzhentsem opredelennoi filosofskoi shkoly? // Mouseion. Professoru A. I. Zaitsevu ko dnyu 70-letiya: sb. statei. SPb., 1997.
Tyzhov A. Ya. Polibii v Rime // Antichnaya grazhdanskaya obshchina. Problemy sotsial'no-politicheskogo razvitiya i ideologii / pod red. E. D. Frolova. L., 1986.
Tyzhov A. Ya. Polibii i ego "Vseobshchaya istoriya" // Polibii. Vseobshchaya istoriya: v 3-kh t. / per. F. G. Mishchenko; pod red. A. Ya. Tyzhova. SPb.: Nauka, 1994. T. 1.
Utchenko C. L. Politicheskie ucheniya drevnego Rima. M., 1977.
Aalders G. J. D. Die Theorie der gemischten Verfassung im Altertum. Amsterdam, 1968.
Cicero M. Tullius. De officiis. Tert. Recognovit C. Atzert. Lipsiae, 1958.
D?rrie H. Megalophanes // Der kleine Pauly. Lexikon der Antike. M?nchen, 1979. Bd. III.
Foucault J.-A. de. Recherches sur la langue et le style de Polybe. Paris, 1972.
Friedlander P. Socrates enters Rome // American Journal of Philology. Baltimore, 1945. Vol. 66.
Fritz K. von. The Theory of the Mixed Constitution in Antiquity. A Critical Analysis of Polybius’ Political Ideal. N. Y., 1956.
G?rtner H. Krates (IV) // Der kleine Pauly. Lexikon der Antike. M?nchen, 1979. Bd. III.
Hercod R. La conception de l?histoire dans Polybe. Lausanne, 1962.
Hirzel R. Untersuchungen zu Ciceros philosophischen Schriften. Leipzig, 1882. Bd. II.
Kornemann E. Zum Staatsrecht des Polybios // Philologus. Leipzig, 1931. Bd. 86.
Laqueur R. Polybius. Leipzig, 1913.
Leo F. Geschichte der r?mischen Literatur. Berlin, 1913. Bd. I.
Osann F. Ueber einige Schriften Dic?archos des Peripatetikers // Beitr?ge zur griechischen und r?mischen Literatur. Darmstadt, 1836. Bd. II.
Pedech P. La m?thode historique de Polybe. Paris, 1964.
Pichon R. Un historien positiviste dans l Antiquit? // Revue Universitaire. Paris, 1986.
Places E. de. Le platonisme de Panetius // M?langes d?arch?ology et d?histoire. Paris, 1956. Vol. 66.
Scala R. von. Die Studien des Polybios. Stuttgart, 1890. Bd. I.
Strasburger H. Der Scipionenkreis // Hermes. Berlin, 1966. Bd. 94. Heft 1.
Taeger F. Die Arch?ologie des Polybios. Stuttgart, 1922.
Tischov A. J. Quomodo Polybius Platonis philosophi opera legerit // Mnemon. Issledovaniya i publikatsii po istorii antichnogo mira / pod red. E. D. Frolova. SPb., 2011. Vyp. 10.
Ziegler K. Ekdemos und Megalophanes oder Ekdelos und Demophanes? // Rheinisches Museum f?r Philologie. Frankfurt am Main, 1934. Bd. 83.
Ziegler K. Polybios (1) // Realencyclopadie der classisschen Altertumswissenschaft. Neue Bearbeitung. Stuttgart, 1952. Bd. XXI.
Ziegler K. Prytanis // Der kleine Pauly. Lexikon der Antike. M?nchen, 1979. Bd. III.
Русский
