Pan-Art Pedagogy. Theory & Practice Philology. Theory & Practice Manuscript

Archive of Scientific Articles

ISSUE:    Historical, Philosophical, Political and Law Sciences, Culturology and Study of Art. Theory & Practice. 2012. Issue 12-1
COLLECTION:    Philosophical Sciences

All issues

License Agreement on scientific materials use.

CATHOLIC MODERNISM: PART OF WESTERN ART NOUVEAU OR SPECIAL REACTION TO IT?

Vladislav Borisovich Dolgov
Orthodox St. Tikhon Classical University
Submitted: October 29, 2012
Abstract. The author reveals the notion Catholic modernism, tells that it turned into an influential liberal movement at the end of the XIXth - the beginning of the XXth century, considers the theological and social-cultural roots of this phenomenon; suggests the typology of its basic directions and the logically coherent description of the most important philosophical-theological conceptions of its most striking main representatives, analyzes the polemics around modernist ideas in connection with Vatican sharply critical reaction to them, and finally reveals the profound influence, which, in spite of papal bans, modernist ideas had on the further development of the Catholic theology during the XXth century, including the reforms of II Vatican Council. The main purpose of the article is to show that being the result of the Western art nouveau and the bearer of reformist ideas, Catholic modernism however suggested certain alternative designed to preserve special Catholic identity and to provide an adequate status for Church in a rapidly changing Western society.
Key words and phrases:
Католическая Церковь
папство
модернизм
Ватиканский собор
Catholic Church
papacy
modernism
Vatican Council
Reader Open the whole article in PDF format. Free PDF-files viewer can be downloaded here.
References:
  1. Гарнак А. Сущность христианства. СПб.: Издание М. В. Пирожкова, 1907. 222 с.
  2. Документы II Ватиканского собора. М.: Паолине, 1998. 589 с.
  3. Леруа Э. Догмат и критика. М., 1915. 322 с.
  4. Пупар П. Церковь и культура. Заметки о пастырстве разума. Милан - Москва: Христианская Россия, 1993. 253 с.
  5. Рауш Т. Католичество в третьем тысячелетии. М.: ББИ, 2007. 400 с.
  6. Bella J. Father Tyrrell's Dogmas // Church History. 1939. Vol. 8. № 4.
  7. Blondel M. L'Action. Paris, 1893. 497 p.
  8. Catholicism Contending with Modernity. Roman Catholic Modernism and Anti-Modernism in Historical Context / ed. by D. Jodock. Cambridge, 2000. 345 p.
  9. Fogarty G. Biblical Scholarschip at the Catholic University of America // The Catholic Historical Review. 1989. Vol. 75. № 4.
  10. Haight R. The Unfolding Modernism in France: Blondel, Laberthonnière, Le Roy // Theological Studies. 1974. Vol. 35.
  11. Houtin A. Histoire du Modernisme Catholique. Paris, 1913. 458 p.
  12. Kurtz L. The Politics of Heresy // The American Journal of Sociology. 1983. Vol. 88. № 6.
  13. La Piana G. A Review of Italian Modernism // The Harvard Theological Review. 1916. Vol. 9. № 4.
  14. Laberthonnière L. Le réalisme chrétien et l'idealisme grec. Paris, 1904. 219 p.
  15. Lilley L. Modernism. A Record and Review. L., 1908. 277 p.
  16. Livingston J. C. Modern Christian Thought. The Enlightenment and the Nineteenth Century. Minneapolis, 2006. Vol. 1. 445 p.
  17. Loisy A. Histoire du canon de'l Ancien Testament. Paris, 1890. 259 p.
  18. Loisy A. Jésus et la tradition évangelique. Paris, 1910. 287 p.
  19. Loisy A. Le Quatrieme Évangile. Paris, 1921. 602 p.
  20. Loisy A. Les Evangiles Synoptiques. Paris, 1907. Vol. 1. 1014 p.
  21. Loisy A. Les Evangiles Synoptiques. Paris, 1907. Vol. 2. 848 p.
  22. Loisy A. The Birth of the Christian Religion. L., 1948. 416 p.
  23. Loisy A. The Gospel and the Church. N. Y., 1904. 277 p.
  24. Loisy A. The Origins of the New Testament. N. Y., 1962. 330 p.
  25. Loisy A. The Religion of Israel. N. Y., 1910. 288 p.
  26. McKown C. Alfred Loisy: Unfaltering Critic // The Journal of Religion. 1942. Vol. 22. № 1.
  27. McNeil J. Freedom of Conscience in Theological Perspectives [Электронный ресурс]. URL: http://www.mauriceblondel.com/ FofCon.pdf (дата обращения: 18.09.2012).
  28. Petre M. Autobiography and Life of George Tyrrell. L., 1912. 512 p.
  29. Ratté J. Three Modernists: Alfred Loisy, George Tyrrell, William L. Sullivan. N. Y., 1967. 370 p.
  30. Reardon B. Roman Catholic Modernism. Stanford, 1970. 251 p.
  31. Sabatier P. Modernism. The Jowett Lectures. N. Y., 1908. 351 p.
  32. Sullivan J. Blondel and a Living Tradition for Catholic Education // A Journal of Inquiry and Practice. 1997. Vol. 1. № 1.
  33. Tyrrell G. Hard Sayings. N. Y., 1904, 1908. 469 p.
  34. Tyrrell G. Lex Orandi. L. - N. Y. - Bombay, 1903. 216 p.
  35. Tyrrell G. Medievalism and Modernism // The Harvard Theological Review. 1908. Vol. 1. № 3.
  36. Tyrrell G. Selected Letters. L., 1920. 301 p.
  37. Tyrrell G. The Faith of the Millions. L. - N. Y. - Bombey, 1904. 344 p.
  38. Tyrrell G. Through Scylla and Charybdis. L. - N. Y. - Bombay - Calcutta, 1907. 386 p.
  39. Vidler A. The Modernist Movement in the Roman Church. Its Origins & Outcome. L., 1934. 286 p.
  40. Wells D. The Pope as Antichrist: the Substance of George Tyrrell's Polemic // The Harvard Theological Review. 1972. Vol. 65. № 2.
All issues


© 2006-2025 GRAMOTA Publishing